Game 3 Discussion

[Unseen]

Feb 24, 2009 15:56:38 GMT -5 Azrael said:

As for you, Mury, what goes on between moderator and player during the night through PMs needs to stay to PMs.

That was last game, cry more

[Azrael]

Bah, oh well, we shall resume tommorrow, unless our staff meeting lasts five minutes. XD

[Corrine Blackbourne]

Ugh... Sorry Everyone. I haven't gotten as much sleep as I would like, and so I'm headed to bed, soon. Also, Heinrich won't SHUT UP about wanting to play Mafia. Who HONESTLY thinks I should let her? I mean, she SAW the signups and everything... I say it's her fault.

[Roan]

These games don't take too long, she can wait

[Corrine Blackbourne]

NIGHT BEGINS!

[Corrine Blackbourne]

DAY BEGINS!

[Corrine Blackbourne]

Tim has named Davi Oldie.

[TJ]

I'm thinking about voting for anyone who voted for Davi. I think it's even possible that Davi could be a vampire/lycan.

It's not logical for a lycan or vampire to vote for a regular student as oldie since the oldie vote counts as two unless they figured somebody would say this and were trying to trick us. Otherwise, I would think the majority of those voting for Davi are lycans or vampires.

In addition, I'm assuming some of the non-voters are also lycans/vampires.

What are your thoughts on this theory?

[Felix I. Genero]

I say whoever doesn't voice opinion often should be considered suspicious.

We have nothing to go on yet, so unless people state their ideas any vote will just be chance and not logic. Seeing how they're more good guys then bad guys, it'll only hurt us to choose randomly.

Someone very logical killed Tim, that's for sure.

[Roan]

Feb 25, 2009 9:44:57 GMT -5 TJ said:

I'm thinking about voting for anyone who voted for Davi. I think it's even possible that Davi could be a vampire/lycan.

It's not logical for a lycan or vampire to vote for a regular student as oldie since the oldie vote counts as two unless they figured somebody would say this and were trying to trick us. Otherwise, I would think the majority of those voting for Davi are lycans or vampires.

In addition, I'm assuming some of the non-voters are also lycans/vampires.

What are your thoughts on this theory?

But by doing this you are assuming Davi is a vampire/lycan right away. We have nothing to go on and you'll probably end up poaching a lot of random students in the process, which will just hurt us.

Also look at the fact that Tim passed on Oldie to Davi. We all know Tim to be smart, it's partially the reason I didn't want him to have the powers of Oldie and it's probably part of the reason he got slaughtered last night. It's not just that he was Oldie. So if he was smart enough to get poached so quickly we'd hope he would be smart enough to choose his replacement Oldie properly and not stick us with a lycan/vampire.

I see flaws in your argument, though I guess it is somewhere to start.

I agree more with Felix's argument. We need to be more wary of those people who don't speak at all. Laying low is an easy way to not get targeted if you're a vampire/lycan.

[TJ]

That's true. I was merely saying it was probably better to vote for someone who didn't vote yesterday or voted for Davi just because anyone who would have voted for Tim would not have voted for a student if they were a lycan/vampire.

Unless they had a counterplan and used this as a misleading scenario? That's more of what I was trying to say.

I wasn't trying to conclude that the Davi voters were all lycans/vampires. I'm just saying it's more likely than those who voted for Tim.

But Devon, that does make sense. I definitely know what you mean.

And Felix brings up excellant points. It's just that we do have to make random stabs in the dark in order to find out who the mafia is. We have a 40-60 chance ratio, but would we rather not vote with that 40% and let the vampires/lycans go 200-0 (doublekill)? We need the most chance idea to vote on unless there's solid proof/evidence or a more logical theory.

[Lucius Dante Infernus]

So much for my plans of survival... I'm full of hemlock, and now, dead. O-o Damn you those who killed my compatriot!

[Adhara Naunet]

Point: It was pretty much a given that Tim was going to be killed off the first night, no matter who was oldie or who's who. We all know he's too sneaky for his own good and should be taken out first, no matter if he seems suspicious or not.

Also, if some of us didn't vote it MAY mean that we were exhausted and decided to go to bed early, rather than the fact that we are suspicious. :-P Just throwing that out there.

[Felix I. Genero]

...we still don't have a victim, other then everyone other then Davi.

[TJ]

We also know that Tybalt is probably one of those who didn't vote, since the person who usually bothers to log on and send GRIM a PM will also usually find half a second to vote.